Brush Strokes and a Seasoned Pan
Educators in Medicine,
In this newsletter, we continue our journey through the fundamentals of AI, its applications in medicine, and its transformative role in faculty development and education. Let’s dive into learning.
I listened to a podcast episode this week that I haven’t stopped thinking about. A friend and mentor - Mark Greenwald - shared it with me. Mark taught me at a national Chief Resident Conference circa 2016, and I have been fortunate to stay in tough with him over the years. He is a family medicine doc, expert educator, and one with great convictions and opinions.
On The Nocturnists, Dr. Emily Silverman sat down with Dr. John Lantos, a pediatrician and bioethicist, to talk about his essay The Lost Aura of the Physician in the Age of Artificial Intelligence.
Give it a listen: The Lost Aura with John Lantos, MD
Once I listend, I immediately shared it with colleagues and all my residents. I am sure you’d enjoy a listen too.
Here are some of my reflections on the chat. Would love to learn some of your thoughts!
🎨 1: The Aura Is in the Brush Strokes
Dr. Lantos borrows the idea of “aura” from the philosopher Walter Benjamin, who was writing about what happens to painting once photography can copy any image. This is an older problem, but one we still grapple with in 2026. An original work of art carries the particular time, place, and skill that made it.
His argument is that the clinical encounter has always had an aura too. One patient, one physician, one conversation, in one moment. He believes that AI didn’t start the erosion of these things, but just the latest step in a long march toward data, standardization, and interchangeable parts.
Here’s where my mind went.
Aura is more than colors. A copy, does not do the art justice. I feel like the 2-d image an artist has a 3rd dimension of the paint stacked on top of each other. there are layers that go into art that I don’t see when viewing the final cut. To go a step further, the 4th dimension of time is never accounted for. An artist may work towards something for years, and you encounter it in seconds. I would be a fool to think I understand it all. Even typing now, understand is such a crazy word: to stand, under- there is a superiority to depth there that one cannot digest in a moment.
Stand in front of a real painting and you can see the brush strokes. The ridges of paint. Where the artist pressed hard and where they barely touched the canvas.
In academic medicine we pass off patients every week and act as though nothing is lost. The labs, vitals, a problem list. The aura of care is not accounted for. This is an obsession over data, CURING, and forgetting about the CARING. I think those two words need a blog post of their own.
What about the look on a daughter’s face in the room? What about the 20 years of practice I’ve seen before today? What about ‘gut feelings’? What about “I know about this person because I’ve seen them for ten years”?
🍳 2: The Seasoned Pan
Dr. Lantos shares his own story as a patient. Facing a heart rhythm problem with no clear guideline (one of his doctors called it an “evidence-free zone”), he gave his data to the large language models and got useful, thoughtful information back.
I believe it. I’m sure the LLMs know the answer.
Knowing the recipe and cooking the meal are different things. My mom is a phenomenal chef. She calls it her “touch” in the kitchen. She doesn’t measure anything when she cooks. No measuring cups, no recipe card, but all expertise, and you can taste it. That’s what gives the food, the art work, its depth.
She likes to cook certain foods in particular pots/pans. A seasoned pan gives flavor that a brand new one can’t. Every meal it has ever cooked left an impact. Clinical expertise is a seasoned pan. Every patient leaves a touch. The recipe is available to everyone now, in seconds. But mom’s touch isn’t.
For educators: Dr. Lantos asks what we should train doctors to do when cramming information is no longer the point. My answer: We teach them to care, to season themselves in the arts of humanism. That can’t be rushed, and it can’t be downloaded.
A few ways to do it in your space:
Protect the fourth dimension. Time with patients who are ill, struggling, hurting, is where depth comes from. Guard it in your curriculum and schedules.
Show your brush strokes. Think out loud. When your touch leads you somewhere, tell your learner why. Explain your pretest probability and why you see something else in the room.
Let AI hold the recipe. Then spend the time it saves at the bedside.
The aura of the physician is in caring. It is up to us if we want to lose it or hold on to it and fuel it. So, bring your touch.
💌 As always, thanks for reading. Get in touch and let me know your thoughts!
Thank you for joining us on this adventure. Stay tuned for more AI insights, best practices, and more future editions of AI+MedEd.
For education and innovation,
Karim
Share this with someone, have them sign up here.

